Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes

We are here to help make your special day stand out!

Place Your Custom Order

You can count on Sugar Rush Columbus for your custom treats!

Our Wedding Cakes are featured in The Knot  and in Wedding Wire

Who doesn’t like a fresh made cookie?

Sugar Rush Columbus offers many different cookies for pickup, eat in or local delivery (delivery charge extra). You may choose to have a select few of our amazing cookies to be shipped nationally! Alaska and Hawaii not included. Send that perfect gift to someone in your life to let them know how lucky you are to know them.

Because of the nature of our cookies and Sugar Rush Columbus wanting you to receive the best product available, certain cookies are only available locally. The cookies available for national shipping are as follows: The OG, Peanut butter Overload, Smores, Jumbo M&M, cookies and cream, Cookie Monster, Somewhere Over the Rainbow, Megadoodle, Oh My Buckeye, and cookie confusion.

Customer Reviews

Sugar Rush Columbus
Based on 490 reviews
review us on
Ordered a 3-tier 50th anniversary cake for our friends' 50th anniversary party to match their traditional style wedding cake with a modern flair. The cake not only was stunning but was delicious. So many people commented on the cake. It truly was spectacular. I've never had a more delicious white cake and yummy buttercream frosting ever. Highly recommend Sugar Rush.
The best desserts for adult sweet tooths and the cutest cookies for kids! 10/10 recommend from our family!
We highly recommend Sugar Rush. My daughter loved her Confetti Graduation cake and it tasted delicious.I can’t wait to get my next cake (which I’ll be picking up in 2 weeks).Thank you to the staff at Sugar Rush. From start to finish you all made our experience easy and enjoyable ❤️
Delicious bakery! My family loves Sugar Rush. We go in and order through Door Dash sometimes. It is a fun atmosphere and the staff is always really pleasant and patient when we take 100 years picking things out.
I ordered a custom cake for my daughter's birthday. It looked amazing! The almond cake was delicious! Super cute decor inside and the staff was so friendly.
Quick withdrawals without being charged a fee and a top-notch trading platform. Everything is excellent. I have been trading with this broker for a few months and so far all seems consistently well. I like this company. I like the fact that they are reliable. I find them reliable and professional. Mr. Killian Bayer is one of my all-time favorites. he replies promptly and most importantly in the right manner. I feel confident trading with he platform and I can rely on this company to succeed in my trades. he has given me great opportunities to earn money. I am glad to have traded with the right brokerage platform. I gain good profit and received my withdrawals earlier.
Words can express how grateful I am Mr. KILLIAN BAYER
Contact him via
WhatsApp: +1 (707) 654-4150
FB: Killian Bayer
Mr. Killian Bayer is a good trader of forex and bitcoins and i will never stop talking about he good works because he earned me a profit of $12,500 with a capital of $1,000 weekly and i am a living testimony of he perfect skills, contact info
WhatsApp: +1 (707) 654-4150
Facebook: Killian Bayer
The 90s kids cookie is 👩‍🍳😘I’m not a big fan of the cupcakes. The icing is a little grainy
I had a custom cake for my niece's 16th birthday and it was so much better than expectations! I also got cupcakes and they went above and beyond. My neice was so excited! They were beautiful AND delicious! Thank you all so much! I will be back!
The best cake in Columbus!
The location is awesome! The atmosphere is nice and a great place to host a get-together. I did purchase a chocolate cake with butter cream icing. To be honest, it lived up to its name. However, I wouldn't recommend it to anyone who has diabetes because it is extra sweet. It was so sweet that the sugar overpowered the cake. It's not my favorite. Nice place
We ordered a birthday cake for my sons 1st birthday! The customer service was exceptional! My sons theme was time flies and I sent them reference photos and discussed the cake over the phone. I had exactly what I wanted in my mind and they came through with exactly what I was thinking! The entire experience was perfect and I was over the moon with this cake. The taste was amazing. My son loved every bit of his smash cake and I will continue to use them for the future.
If you are looking for delicious, one of a kind custom cake or cookies, you want Sugar Rush! Ordered 3 custom cakes & cookies for my 60th birthday party and they were even better than imagined! I went in with a theme in my head, and Frank and his team brought it to life. Best cakes in the entire city!! Weddings, parties, kids parties, BBQs….Sugar Rush can do it! Did I mention they also have a bar for adult beverages!
Delicious unique treats and cakes with the best buttercream I've ever had!
There is a huge variety here & a fun atmosphere! You MUST have a huge sweet tooth because the frosting is extremely sweet.
The literal BEST. We ordered our wedding cake through them. We had a two-tier wedding cake and 3 mini cakes. One of the mini cakes was a suprise birthday cake for my husband! It was a last minute addition and it was a Marvel/comic book cake. They did a happy birthday banner on the cake and added pictures of my husband's favorite heroes. Frank was SO easy to work with and was super nice!! Everything was made clear to me on what we were getting. I gave them my color scheme and let them go at it! The cake decorator KILLED IT. Our cakes looked amazing and tasted even better!! We had salted caramel, lemon blueberry, confetti, red velvet, and white. We were getting compliments all night about the cake!!! AND they even delivered which took off some stress! 10/10 would order from them again!
So many choices for whatever kind of sweet flavor you're craving! Highly recommend by me and my entire family!
Absolutely love this bakery! They have the most amazing baked goods around! They are always so nice and have a great selection of fresh treats everyday! Definitely check out Sugar Rush it’s delicious! 😋
We ordered our wedding cake from them and some cupcakes, and it was just a phenomenal experience. They were so great at taking our ideas and executing it even better than we imagined it. The staff is so kind and helpful every step of the way. Oh, and everything they make is beyond delicious. They have become our bakers for all future events. Thank you so much Sugar Rush!
We loved our cake & cookies!!
Thank you for making the most beautiful and delicious cupcakes for my daughters birthday. My husband loved the chocolate top, so much that he got two slices. We'll definitely be coming back for more in the future
Wonderfully amazing pumpkin donuts! Tried one as soon as I got to the car
Not only are the cakes beautiful, they are DELICIOUS!
Our wedding cake was fabulous and delicious... and the cake pops and cupcakes!!! OMG!!!
The whole experience was great. From the initial phone call, to picking up and seeing what was created, to finally eating it. Highly suggest this bakery if you’d like something creative, something different. They listened to all my ideas then mixed that with their own take and what was made was an awesome cake for my son. Very happy! Thank you guys.
I just came there for the breakfast today. And wow! I got some croissant, a classic cinnamon roll and the apple cinnamon roll! Absolutely loved everything. The cinnamon rolls were delicious but too sweet for my own taste. My husband who is a sweets lover absolutely adored and devoured it all! The croissant were my favorite! Sweet but not overly sweet. Can’t wait to return for more breakfast and normal everyday options! 10/10!!!!!
Fantastic place, one of our favorites to get desserts from! While not all flavors may meet every persons pallet, there is near guaranteed to be something here you'll like!My recommendation is the lemon blueberry cupcake.One of the best I've ever had!
Very yummy treats, and extremely friendly staff.
I’ve attended a cake decorating and cookie decorating class. I’ve ordered from the case and had a specialty cake designed. Everything has always tasted amazing, including their sweet drinks from the bar. The cake design for my 16 year old niece was left to bakers discretion so long as it incorporated Dolly Parton, Jennifer Coolidge, and McLovin. She couldn’t have been happier. Staff is always friendly and knowledgeable. A must visit if you are in it around Reynoldsburg!
We’ve gotten all of our special event desserts from here. From our wedding cake to our baby shower cupcakes they never fail to impress. Always friendly with great service and fresh products. Churro is the best flavor by far!
We ordered our wedding cake from here and it was amazing so beautiful and tasty, everyone loved it.. the price was great and well worth, I'll definitely order again! The people there are helpful and friendly such a great place
Definitely worth the stop while in Columbus! Service was awesome and let's talk about the sweet treats....WOW! We bought almost one if everything. It did not disappoint, so good!
Staff was very friendly. Great shakes and sweets.
Awesome job on the custom cake!
Today was the first time I have personally purchased from Sugar Rush, but have had their cakes from a friend. I had a large order that reserved online (super easy process by the way) for cinnamon rolls. I did not realize how huge these things were going to be! (Totally my bad, but they will get eaten!) I had a fairly large order with a bunch of cinnamon rolls, cupcakes, and cookies. I had my baby in the carseat and was somehow going to carry it all to the car, totally thinking multiple trips. The gentleman working there, that had taken care of me from start to finish, carried my stuff to my car. He was sooo amazing and sweet! I could not have had a better experience with them! Every single thing that I got was absolutely amazing!!!
I've been a client of Sugar Rush for years, thanks to a long-term employee of theirs named Carol and I can't say enough good things about them! I was blown away by her skills and creativity, so when she began her journey at Sugar Rush, I knew I had to continue my cake journey with them. If you have a vision in mind for a cake, I highly recommend Carol. She has an incredible talent for bringing ideas to life and creating cakes that exceed expectations. You won't be disappointed!Looking back on all the cakes they've made for me over the years is such a joy. Each one is a masterpiece, and it's amazing to see how they've evolved and perfected their craft. I love admiring their work and reminiscing about the special moments each cake has been a part of.What sets Sugar Rush apart is their ability to turn my visions into reality. No matter how crazy or unique my ideas may be, they always manage to bring them to life. Their attention to detail is impeccable, and the end result is always a stunning work of art that becomes the center of attention at every event.I can't tell you how many times people have approached me at parties and other gatherings, asking who could create such incredible cakes. Sugar Rush has truly set the bar high, and there's no other competition in Columbus or the surrounding areas that even comes close.But it's not just their talent that makes me appreciate them so much. The team at Sugar Rush is incredibly friendly, professional, and dedicated. They go above and beyond to ensure that every cake is not only visually stunning but also delicious. Their wide variety of flavors are out of this world, and they never disappoint.Mandy, the owner of Sugar Rush, has a heart of gold. She's not only talented but also incredibly kind and caring. Her passion for creating beautiful cakes shines through in every creation. You can feel the love and dedication she puts into her work, and it's truly inspiring.And let's not forget about Frank! He's the one who makes anything happen around there. He's like the magician behind the scenes, ensuring that everything runs smoothly and that every cake is delivered with perfection!⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I ordered a memorial cake for my daughters birthday. This was her 1st birthday in Heaven. They recommended a rainbow cake and they added 2 purple butterflies. Heathers favorite color was purple. The cake was amazing and so moist. The icing was the best icing I have ever tasted! Again thank you so much for everything and taking the time to make this day special for her 10year old son Ayden and our family.
I felt welcome by the gentleman behind the counter, he was super friendly and even told us a story about the Big Narwhal cookie, lol. The cupcakes and cookies are huge and soooo tasty. There are so many options it’s hard to pick just a few so I bought an array of baked goods to sample and share with my family. I will definitely be returning with my grandson to have a milkshake the size of my head. And maybe a trip with some gals for an alcoholic beverage!The Willy Wonka version of baked goods and yes there’s candy there too!
Sugar Rush did such a great job got my wedding! everything with so beautiful and tasty! they definitely did not disappoint! will be recommending them to anyone and everyone! they deserve all the hype!
wow I can't say enough good things about this bakery and the people. The customer service too! The creme Brule cinnamon rolls are literally the BEST I've ever had! My family has tried almost everything in the store. I did a lot more shopping local this year. This place we have hit monthly. my daughter took a cake class on early Decemner. She loved it! She said it was amazing fun and the lady was so nice and very passionate about baking.
Everyone we came in contact with at Sugar Rush was very informative and nice. We ordered a wedding cake with short notice. Sugar Rush was not only accommodating they were easy to work with and very delicious! I would definitely recommend Sugar Rush to all my family and friends!!
We ordered a birthday cake for our twins and it was absolutely perfect!!!! The details were wonderful and it’s by far the best tasting Cale I’ve had locally!!!
Sugar Rush created my daughter’s college graduation cake exactly how I envisioned! The cake was GORGEOUS! Every side was incredibly detailed and done exactly as discussed. The “Lizzie Maguire” sculptures were to replicate my daughter and turned out just like the pics! The cake was incredibly DELICIOUS! We had red velvet and yellow, and both layers were fresh and moist. My family and friends were so impressed that a cake that looked this amazing could taste equally as great! Thank you Mandy, Frank and staff! You made our day!
Amazing cupcakes! Highly recommend the tiramisu with the little dropper of espresso and the lemon blueberry. Also delicious were the s'mores one and the salted caramel. Will definitely return to try others!
What can I...Frank and his team did it again!!! This cake and cupcakes were for my mom's 70th birthday and they were out of this world fabulous and delicious. I'm a loyal customer and I'm going to keep buying these fabulous cakes from the best cake rock stars in town!!! Thank you so much for making my mom's birthday that much special! The cake and cupcakes were the talk of the party.The Gucci cake was exactly how it was in the picture I submitted: the top layer was lemon drop and the bottom layer was cherry limeade.The cupcakes were two different flavors: orange mimosa and pina colada. Anything you want them to do not only would they do it but exceed all expectations.-Mia Watkins
We got my birthday cake there and it was beautiful and delicious! Everything we have tried there has been delicious. We recommend Sugar Rush to everyone.
So good and delightful. Store is very cool with an awesome atmosphere.
Love this place they never let me down! This past weekend I placed an order for a baby shower cake and EVERYONE was obsessed with the cake it was so moist. We did strawberry and cookies and cream *franks suggestion* and it did not disappoint!
Will be coming back more often.
Sweet change from the commercial cakes bought from the grocery stores.
My daughter had such a great time at the cake decorating class! Amanda did such a good job teaching the kids!
Recently I stopped in to grab some treats for a sports banquet. The order was created to perfection, handled with care, and tasted oh, so sweet!!!!!!BY FAR some of the BEST desserts on the east side; possibly the whole city of Columbus!Lastly, they offer classes that are fun for the whole family, team, or office! (ps: they also have adult beverages now!)Check them out when you needs treats for your next event or want to plan a day of baking!
Tried the sampler box on my birthday... Really good cupcakes especially the Mimosa one :) definitely want to come back as there's still so many things I want to try. Excellent customer service!!
I have bought Sugar Rush cookies for coworkers and to give as gifts, everyone I have given then to have fell in love with them. They are so much better than crumble Cookie. Their cupcakes are amazing too. Defiantly continuing to go back for my baked good needs. Staff are also so nice and helpful.
The team at Sugar Rush is amazingly talented! The service is outstanding. They listened to what I wanted and the results were more than I expected… I will be a long time customer!
My whole family loves Sugar Rush! My 11 year old daughter is autistic and this is one of her favorite places. It is her happy place. The atmosphere is so fun. The staff is always so pleasant and helpful and all the treats are delicious.
Hands down the coolest bakery around! The staff and owners are amazing people and as a community we are incredibly lucky to have them so close! Very proud of them for all their hard work! Highly recommend them!!
Picked up 4 dozen cupcakes for my husband’s surprise birthday party. Ordered the mystery flavors. Cupcakes were designed beautifully! The taste was amazing! Hands down the best cupcakes I have ever had. Very reasonably priced!Found my new bakery for birthdays and special occasions.
Friend had a Louis Vuitton cake made for me. Its was beautiful and absolutely delicious!
I ordered a custom heart shaped cake for my daughter's birthday. It was fabulous. It was exactly what I wanted and more. Wish I could share the picture
As an avid sweet lover, I'm surprised it took me so long to come here, especially since I've lived in this area for over 2 years now. The bakery is on a strip with a few other stores (places seem to come and go over here). My husband and I arrived at a half hour after they opened so it wasn't busy. The decor is cute and I love the gummy bears. 😍 There are tons of cupcake, cake, cookie, cake pop, and macaroon options. Additionally, you can get those Instagrammable milkshakes from here, too, and boozy milkshakes. 🍨 My husband and I picked out three cookies: creme brule, s'mores, and cosmic brownie. So far I've sampled small pieces of the s'mores and brownie cookies and they are good. 🍪 Not too sweet, not hard, and not gooey. The cookies are cute large, so they can come off as kinda dry at times. In comparison to Crumbl, though, I'd pick these any day. 🙌🏻 I'd be interested in ordering a cake from here sometime.
I am satisfied every time I go here!! I just had them do a cake for my husband's birthday and they killed it!! They are officially my party/dessert supplier for any occasion in my future!!
Frank just did my Wedding Cake and Cake Pops for my Grands. I recommend you try the Raspberry and Strawberry Cake! So flavorful and refreshing! Frosting was Amazing and smooth! Awesome atmosphere at the store too!! He now has a long term customer since I will be relocating to Columbus!

Local Businesses
We Recommend