Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes

We are here to help make your special day stand out!

Place Your Custom Order

You can count on Sugar Rush Columbus for your custom treats!

Our Wedding Cakes are featured in The Knot  and in Wedding Wire

Who doesn’t like a fresh made cookie?

Sugar Rush Columbus offers many different cookies for pickup, eat in or local delivery (delivery charge extra). You may choose to have a select few of our amazing cookies to be shipped nationally! Alaska and Hawaii not included. Send that perfect gift to someone in your life to let them know how lucky you are to know them.

Because of the nature of our cookies and Sugar Rush Columbus wanting you to receive the best product available, certain cookies are only available locally. The cookies available for national shipping are as follows: The OG, Peanut butter Overload, Smores, Jumbo M&M, cookies and cream, Cookie Monster, Somewhere Over the Rainbow, Megadoodle, Oh My Buckeye, and cookie confusion.

Customer Reviews

My Sisters and I ordered a custom cake for our Mom’s 85th Birthday celebration. Frank and team captured our vision beautifully. The cake looked amazing and was deliciously tasting. We are definitely ordering future delectables.
I ordered a German chocolate cake and birthday cake and salted caramel cupcakes for my mom's 70th birthday.everything was phenomenal, the customer service during the ordering process, the seamless pickup, and absolutely delicious cake and cupcakes, the birthday gal was very pleased!
We ordered a custom cake for my mom’s birthday. We wanted something beautiful, understated, and delicious. That is exactly what we got! Everyone raved about the cake. We have been fans of the cookies and cupcakes for years, but this was our first custom cake. It won’t be the last!
Great place with amazing staff. Love coming here
I personally don't even like cake .
I attended a graduation party in 2023 where they served a Sugar Rush cake ,I took a small slice home to be polite 🤦‍♀️one bite and I'm messaging the hostess asking where did you get that cake ...I've been hooked ever since .I've bought thier quick cakes and done custom orders neither have disappointed.
I highly recommend !
We stumbled upon this place by accident while doing some shopping in the area, but once we saw it, we knew that we had to check it out.

As we walked in, we kept saying to each other, "look at this one", or "how about that one", until eventually each if us had picked out a sweet treat to try, and we absolutely everything that we had.

The staff was amazing and made us feel like we were the most important people that they had seen all day.

We will definitely be coming back again and again.
Best customer service ever! I’ve had two cakes from here and several sets of cupcakes in store and DoorDash and it’s always amazing. I will not go anywhere else for birthday cakes.
My cake was perfect! Sugar Rush really came thru with the creation of my chocolate cake. It was very delicious! Definitely going back to try more tasty treats!
When I walked on the door, I was treated with kindness laughter and so much respect from the Owners. The cookies was huge and Delicious. Yes I will definitely come back Strawberry Cheesecake cookies was my favorite 😍
My daughter has done a couple of cake classes SHE JUST CANT GET ENOUGH. My favorite are the holiday cookies to decorate at home ❤️ this place just so much fun!
The best desserts for adult sweet tooths and the cutest cookies for kids! 10/10 recommend from our family!
I order cakes from Sugar Rush for every birthday, graduation, and special occasion in our family, and they never disappoint. The cakes are not only stunning to look at but absolutely delicious—our guests are always impressed, and I’m constantly asked where they come from. From ordering to pickup, the process is effortless, and the staff is always welcoming, professional, and kind. Sugar Rush truly goes above and beyond, and I can’t recommend them enough. If you want to wow your guests and make your celebration unforgettable, order from them—you’ll be glad you did!
Delicious bakery! My family loves Sugar Rush. We go in and order through Door Dash sometimes. It is a fun atmosphere and the staff is always really pleasant and patient when we take 100 years picking things out.
Quick withdrawals without being charged a fee and a top-notch trading platform. Everything is excellent. I have been trading with this broker for a few months and so far all seems consistently well. I like this company. I like the fact that they are reliable. I find them reliable and professional. Mr. Killian Bayer is one of my all-time favorites. he replies promptly and most importantly in the right manner. I feel confident trading with he platform and I can rely on this company to succeed in my trades. he has given me great opportunities to earn money. I am glad to have traded with the right brokerage platform. I gain good profit and received my withdrawals earlier.
Words can express how grateful I am Mr. KILLIAN BAYER
Contact him via
WhatsApp: +1 (707) 654-4150
Email: killianbayer704@gmail.com
FB: Killian Bayer
We just moved to Ohio and I needed a birthday cake for my daughter. This place was absolutely amazing! They made exactly what we wanted and it was the most delicious cake I have ever had. I’m a home baker and would normally make their cakes myself. I can honestly say I will not be doing that anymore. This cake was delicious and the buttercream was absolutely perfect! Their prices are great for what you get, and I will be using them again!
The best cake in Columbus!
A couple years ago our granddaughter went to a children's cake baking "camp" there. She absolutely LOVED it. And we got to enjoy her unique creation...and it was delicious!! Awesome!
We ordered a birthday cake for my sons 1st birthday! The customer service was exceptional! My sons theme was time flies and I sent them reference photos and discussed the cake over the phone. I had exactly what I wanted in my mind and they came through with exactly what I was thinking! The entire experience was perfect and I was over the moon with this cake. The taste was amazing. My son loved every bit of his smash cake and I will continue to use them for the future.
Order cupcakes and custom cake pops for a baby shower a bit ago. Gave a reference image and whoever made them made it look identical to the image. The taste was amazing and everyone loved them at the party.
I picked them up the DAY BEFORE and was told to keep the cupcakes and cake pops cool until they were ready to be served and even after a 2.5 hour car drive and then a night in the fridge they were perfect for the next day!
I was absolutely obsessed with them and so was everyone else at the party 🥰🥰
Need an excuse to do another custom order sometime soon ♥️
Delicious unique treats and cakes with the best buttercream I've ever had!
We have ordered multiple cakes, cupcakes & cookies for birthdays & we love them. They are always delicious & look perfect! Thank you, Sugar Rush!!
The literal BEST. We ordered our wedding cake through them. We had a two-tier wedding cake and 3 mini cakes. One of the mini cakes was a suprise birthday cake for my husband! It was a last minute addition and it was a Marvel/comic book cake. They did a happy birthday banner on the cake and added pictures of my husband's favorite heroes. Frank was SO easy to work with and was super nice!! Everything was made clear to me on what we were getting. I gave them my color scheme and let them go at it! The cake decorator KILLED IT. Our cakes looked amazing and tasted even better!! We had salted caramel, lemon blueberry, confetti, red velvet, and white. We were getting compliments all night about the cake!!! AND they even delivered which took off some stress! 10/10 would order from them again!
Sugar Rush is fabulous!
I’ve always loved their case items so they were a no brainer for my birthday cake for my 30th birthday.
They were very kind and informative throughout the entire process.
When we picked up the cake, they gave us clear and easy to follow instructions on how to care for the cake and cut the cake when the time came.
All my friends raved over the cake and how delicious it was!
I couldn’t have been happier!
We ordered our wedding cake from them and some cupcakes, and it was just a phenomenal experience. They were so great at taking our ideas and executing it even better than we imagined it. The staff is so kind and helpful every step of the way. Oh, and everything they make is beyond delicious. They have become our bakers for all future events. Thank you so much Sugar Rush!
I absolutely loved my cake I had made for my birthday! I had an almond cake with vanilla buttercream, and it was delicious! I also sent in a reference photo, and they made it nearly identical. I will be ordering again in the future!
We loved our cake & cookies!!
The Sugar Rush team is amazing! We are always greeted with a smile and it's always a super inviting atmosphere! Their cakes and every treat we have had from there is delicious! My new favorite is their fruit pastries! Love this business!
Wonderfully amazing pumpkin donuts! Tried one as soon as I got to the car
We have frequented Sugar Rush Columbus countless times and have NEVER had a bad experience! They have done desserts for us for a tea party themed party, been our favorite go to spot for last minute cupcake, THE BEST crazy milkshakes and always have plenty of cakes ready to go if you need one in a flash! Customer service is just as amazing as their sweets! Our family will ALWAYS patronize Sugar Rush Columbus as long as their doors remain open! Highly recommend! 10/10!
Not only are the cakes beautiful, they are DELICIOUS!
I just came there for the breakfast today. And wow! I got some croissant, a classic cinnamon roll and the apple cinnamon roll! Absolutely loved everything. The cinnamon rolls were delicious but too sweet for my own taste. My husband who is a sweets lover absolutely adored and devoured it all! The croissant were my favorite! Sweet but not overly sweet. Can’t wait to return for more breakfast and normal everyday options! 10/10!!!!!
Fantastic place, one of our favorites to get desserts from! While not all flavors may meet every persons pallet, there is near guaranteed to be something here you'll like!

My recommendation is the lemon blueberry cupcake. One of the best I've ever had!
Very yummy treats, and extremely friendly staff.
I go to Suagr Rush for their cupcakes and they never disappoint! I HIGHLY recommend them!
We’ve gotten all of our special event desserts from here. From our wedding cake to our baby shower cupcakes they never fail to impress. Always friendly with great service and fresh products. Churro is the best flavor by far!
Thank you for creating custom cake pops for the 8th grade class last Spring. They were done in school colors and the kids loved them.
Definitely worth the stop while in Columbus! Service was awesome and let's talk about the sweet treats....WOW! We bought almost one if everything. It did not disappoint, so good!
Sugar Rush did adorable cake pops and absolutely stunning custom cookies for my bridal shower. The cake pops were full of flavor and so moist. They were honestly the best cake pops I’ve ever had. We ordered vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet (which was a fan favorite).

As for the custom cookies—Not only did they look incredible, they tasted incredible! Usually the fancy cookies with royal icing leave a lot to be desired as far as taste goes but these were delicious—it’s been a few months since my shower and I still get comments on how delicious and beautiful the treats were! Thank you Sugar Rush!
Staff was very friendly. Great shakes and sweets.
Today was the first time I have personally purchased from Sugar Rush, but have had their cakes from a friend. I had a large order that reserved online (super easy process by the way) for cinnamon rolls. I did not realize how huge these things were going to be! (Totally my bad, but they will get eaten!) I had a fairly large order with a bunch of cinnamon rolls, cupcakes, and cookies. I had my baby in the carseat and was somehow going to carry it all to the car, totally thinking multiple trips. The gentleman working there, that had taken care of me from start to finish, carried my stuff to my car. He was sooo amazing and sweet! I could not have had a better experience with them! Every single thing that I got was absolutely amazing!!!
Ordered a cake last minute for my little sisters birthday and it was PERFECT! We had so many compliments throughout the night; I’m not even a sweets person, but I ate off of the leftovers for days!
I ordered a memorial cake for my daughters birthday. This was her 1st birthday in Heaven. They recommended a rainbow cake and they added 2 purple butterflies. Heathers favorite color was purple. The cake was amazing and so moist. The icing was the best icing I have ever tasted! Again thank you so much for everything and taking the time to make this day special for her 10year old son Ayden and our family.
Frank and Mandy…y’all always make my birthdays super super special!!! The cupcakes and the chocolate and caramel pretzels were the talk of the party!!! Seriously the best cake and treat makers in Columbus!!!!
This bakery is hands down one of the best around. They opened during the pandemic and have been thriving ever since — and it’s easy to see why. Every single time I walk in, the customer service is unmatched. You can tell they truly care about their customers and take pride in what they do.

Their custom cakes are next-level. The designs are stunning, the flavors are incredible, and they always exceed expectations. And don’t even get me started on their case items — everything from the cookies to the brownies to the macarons is absolutely to die for. You can taste the quality and passion in every bite.

If you’ve been wanting to support a small, local business, this is the one. Mandy and her crew are the real deal. She’s so down-to-earth, kind, and genuinely passionate about her craft. Supporting them means supporting people who pour their heart into their work. Highly, highly recommend!
Found Sugar Rush quite by accident when we decided to do a little shopping after lunch today. Our eyes got wide at the size of the treats they had available. Everything we bought tasted absolutely wonderful. The owner spent a little time chatting with us as it wasn't busy and answered our questions about the business. (Lovely fellow.) We will definitely come by the next time we're in the Columbus area.
My only complaint is that they're not on my side of town so I can't visit regularly but I'm sure my diabetes appreciates that
Absolutely love Sugar Rush. They were professional and creative with our very nerdy Halloween Wedding. The cakes were not only delicious, but fun and impeccably decorated.
We always get our cakes and cupcakes at Sugar Rush. The service is spot on and the cupcakes are delicious. We also get Mondter shakes as an occasional treat. I love trying the seasonal flavors but usually get the peanut butter. You can’t go wrong at Sugar Rush!
I’ve been a customer since before they had their own storefront. The cakes are delicious and you can tell they care about their products. I recently took a bunch of goodies to a friend out of town and she loved them.. they didn’t last long at all. I LOVE their speciality cookies. Highly recommend!
we got a Frozen themed cake here and loooved it! They also got the “vision” when I needed the “scary snowman” from Frozen NOT Olaf (per the toddlers request!” It was so perfect and made her birthday one to remember!

We’ve also been back since our first experience was so great and I got takeaway items from the case, and all the cookies and treats were so fun and tasty
We visited Sugar Rush while we were passing through for a concert. What a fun bakery with fantastic baked goods. Definitely worth the trip. Cookies and cupcakes were fantastic!
My family has used Sugar Rush for multiple occasions and have been pleased every time! Everything is fresh and tastes amazing!! We will continue to support them!!
It's my favorite time of year! Time for butter beer!!! These are my favorite cupcakes at Sugar Rush! Sugar Rush is amazing. I have ordered several birthday cakes here and have never been let down. My kids and I have attended several of the cake workshops and we are always made to feel like family.
This place is so great for sweet treats. The staff is always very friendly and their assortment is amazing. I don’t think you’ll. E disappointed. We always enjoy stopping in for a sweet treat while we’re out and about.
I first heard about sugar rush from the Columbus foodie/facebooks Columbus foodies page and when I seen the cupcakes and seen that the Columbus foodie card got me a discount there I knew I had to try it! Me and my kids went later in the day but they still had a decent amount of options available. My kids picked the dirt style cupcakes each, I grabbed a Jason samosa, and a pineapple upside down one and then also grabbed a blueberry one and a strawberry cheesecake which is what the employee suggested and I ended up giving to my mom, she loved it! The place was clean, the worker was helpful. Will be back again!
I have done custom cake pops and a small cake from Sugar Rush. Both times I was met with professionalism, creativity, and clear instructions on how consume! I would definitely go there again. Very tasty treats!!
Sugar Rush always delivers.. Amazing tasty desserts, the creativity is insane and the service is top Knotch.. Thank you .
We had an excellent experience with Sugar Rush, yet again! This cake design was exactly what we hoped it would be, and oh my goodness the flavor! Highly recommend!
I bought custom cupcakes for my children’s birthdays multiple times and the cupcakes are always beautiful and delicious.
Awesome bakery, have had many custom cakes made. Great flavor and easy to work with, beautiful cakes!!!
I stopped in for the first time for my 50th birthday to buy myself a cake out of the case. I had been following Sugar Rush for awhile but was never able to come in due to living out of town. Anyway, I made it in and saw some amazing treats! It took some time to decide, but I chose a Buckeye cake to take home and enjoy with my family. The staff behind the counter was so helpful and polite while I took that time. That cake was A-MAZ-ING!! We will definitely be back when we’re in the area to try the other treats you have. So yummy! 10/10 recommend
Sugar Rush has the most amazing cupcake flavors and the most variety available of anywhere I know of in the Columbus area. I am very particular about cake; it has to be moist and it has to have real frosting—none of that whipped stuff. Anytime someone in my friend group has a birthday and wants cake, this is where we get it from. We order a dozen variety, and that way everyone can pick what flavor they want and everyone ends up happy. Plus, they have my favorite cake flavor: cotton candy. It's impossible to find that cake flavor anywhere else!
We have been visiting Sugar Rush since it first opened, and have had amazing experiences each and every visit discovering all the delicious treats they have to offer.
Most recently, we ordered a custom cake for our daughter’s first birthday and the process was great from start to finish! We were contacted a couple days after submitting the custom request online to go over all the details with one of the owners, who was great to talk to, walked us through the process, and really took the time to understand what we were looking for. Day of pickup, they took the time to go over everything we needed to know to transport the cake safely and how long it needed to sit before cutting; they even walked it out to our car to make sure it would be safe and stable for the drive to the party. The cake was perfect, we had tons of compliments and people asking where we got such a great cake! (Also I was SUPER impressed that NONE of the blue icing from the smash cupcake stained! MOM APPROVED!) It tasted just as great as it looked, and we will definitely be coming back to Sugar Rush for our next custom cake! (But we will be sure to visit for some sweet treats in the meantime!)

Local Businesses
We Recommend