Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes

We are here to help make your special day stand out!

Place Your Custom Order

You can count on Sugar Rush Columbus for your custom treats!

Our Wedding Cakes are featured in The Knot  and in Wedding Wire

Who doesn’t like a fresh made cookie?

Sugar Rush Columbus offers many different cookies for pickup, eat in or local delivery (delivery charge extra). You may choose to have a select few of our amazing cookies to be shipped nationally! Alaska and Hawaii not included. Send that perfect gift to someone in your life to let them know how lucky you are to know them.

Because of the nature of our cookies and Sugar Rush Columbus wanting you to receive the best product available, certain cookies are only available locally. The cookies available for national shipping are as follows: The OG, Peanut butter Overload, Smores, Jumbo M&M, cookies and cream, Cookie Monster, Somewhere Over the Rainbow, Megadoodle, Oh My Buckeye, and cookie confusion.

Customer Reviews

I’m very picky when it comes to cake, I dislike store bought cakes and theIt gross icing that taste like sugar paste. Sugar Rush has the BEST buttercream icing! The cake is the perfect texture as well. My entire family loves their cake. The cakes... are beautiful as well. They offer adorable cake decorating classes for you to bring your little ones for some fun! My daughter had a blast! Great prices as well! We haven’t tried their other goodies yet but definitely will on our next trip! Five stars for sure!read more
tatum russell
tatum russell
15:21 30 Dec 22
The best cake in Columbus!
Tatum Russell
Tatum Russell
15:23 30 Dec 22
Excellent service and our cake was perfect!!
Tammy Moore
Tammy Moore
00:00 13 Dec 22
We ordered a birthday cake for my sons 1st birthday! The customer service was exceptional! My sons theme was time flies and I sent them reference photos and discussed the cake over the phone. I had exactly what I wanted in my mind and they came... through with exactly what I was thinking! The entire experience was perfect and I was over the moon with this cake. The taste was amazing. My son loved every bit of his smash cake and I will continue to use them for the future.read more
Sierra Marsh
Sierra Marsh
01:26 12 Dec 22
Amazing and fresh.
Chanler Grensted
Chanler Grensted
03:51 05 Dec 22
Delicious unique treats and cakes with the best buttercream I've ever had!
Kim Cashdollar
Kim Cashdollar
15:52 02 Dec 22
I use sugar rush every year for my sons birthday cakes! They always turn out amazing
skyler Martin
skyler Martin
22:02 01 Dec 22
The literal BEST. We ordered our wedding cake through them. We had a two-tier wedding cake and 3 mini cakes. One of the mini cakes was a suprise birthday cake for my husband! It was a last minute addition and it was a Marvel/comic book cake. They... did a happy birthday banner on the cake and added pictures of my husband's favorite heroes. Frank was SO easy to work with and was super nice!! Everything was made clear to me on what we were getting. I gave them my color scheme and let them go at it! The cake decorator KILLED IT. Our cakes looked amazing and tasted even better!! We had salted caramel, lemon blueberry, confetti, red velvet, and white. We were getting compliments all night about the cake!!! AND they even delivered which took off some stress! 10/10 would order from them again!read more
Kaylynn Gallant
Kaylynn Gallant
14:24 27 Nov 22
The literal BEST. We ordered our wedding cake through them. We had a two-tier wedding cake and 3 mini cakes. One of the mini cakes was a suprise birthday cake for my husband! It was a last minute addition and it was a Marvel/comic book cake. They... did a happy birthday banner on the cake and added pictures of my husband's favorite heroes. Frank was SO easy to work with and was super nice!! Everything was made clear to me on what we were getting. I gave them my color scheme and let them go at it! The cake decorator KILLED IT. Our cakes looked amazing and tasted even better!! We had salted caramel, lemon blueberry, confetti, red velvet, and white. We were getting compliments all night about the cake!!! AND they even delivered which took off some stress! 10/10 would order from them again!read more
Kaylynn
Kaylynn
14:08 27 Nov 22
Sugar Rush made the cakes for my son's and daughter's birthday. the cakes were perfect and so cute! The best part is that the cakes were also delicious!! I'll be back for cakes in the future.
Michelle Howell
Michelle Howell
15:29 25 Nov 22
I’m sitting in the parking lot of Sugar Rush, just walked out with my cupcakes, cookies & buckeye.. they are the BEST in Columbus, taste delicious & Josh and his wife and awesome, great job guys!
just4age1
just4age1
14:34 08 Nov 22
So many choices for whatever kind of sweet flavor you're craving! Highly recommend by me and my entire family!
Cassie Cooper
Cassie Cooper
20:56 05 Nov 22
Great customer service. Very professional. Cakes are awesome! It’s a must try!
Eric Foote
Eric Foote
14:27 06 Nov 22
We ordered our wedding cake from them and some cupcakes, and it was just a phenomenal experience. They were so great at taking our ideas and executing it even better than we imagined it. The staff is so kind and helpful every step of the way. Oh,... and everything they make is beyond delicious. They have become our bakers for all future events. Thank you so much Sugar Rush!read more
Lacey Hall
Lacey Hall
20:53 31 Oct 22
All of their sweets taste just as amazing as they look! So many choices for whatever kind of sweet flavor you're craving! Highly recommend by me and my entire family!
Cassie Cooper
Cassie Cooper
21:09 05 Nov 22
We loved our cake & cookies!!
Lori Angell
Lori Angell
21:45 26 Oct 22
Love this place! The owners are the sweetest and super creative. I’ve had the opportunity to work with them for private events and they deliver and execute with perfection every time! If your looking for the best sweet in town for a snack or hand... crafted treats for a private event, go here!read more
Kate Mesa
Kate Mesa
16:17 04 Nov 22
Wonderfully amazing pumpkin donuts! Tried one as soon as I got to the car
Chelsie Lynn-Marie
Chelsie Lynn-Marie
18:04 12 Oct 22
Great bakery, always a huge hit for my kiddos!!!! They have the best cakes, cupcakes, cookies and milkshakes!! Their customer service is always top notch!!! They also offer cake classes which is awesome!!! Get to Sugar Rush now, you won’t be... disappointed!!!read more
Erika Hoover
Erika Hoover
12:06 04 Nov 22
Not only are the cakes beautiful, they are DELICIOUS!
Liz Richardson
Liz Richardson
12:39 10 Oct 22
We never have to think twice about where to go to get something unique and creative. Everything always tastes amazing! Great people!
Matthew Foster
Matthew Foster
11:12 04 Nov 22
The whole experience was great. From the initial phone call, to picking up and seeing what was created, to finally eating it. Highly suggest this bakery if you’d like something creative, something different. They listened to all my ideas then mixed... that with their own take and what was made was an awesome cake for my son. Very happy! Thank you guys.read more
Ryann Nicole
Ryann Nicole
11:40 25 Sep 22
I have placed several orders with Sugar Rush and I have never been disappointed by them. They catered for my wedding and all the guests loved it. You can also go in and get stuff out of the cases. Wonderful place for all things sweet.
Anne Sullivan-Browning
Anne Sullivan-Browning
16:50 01 Nov 22
1st time going yesterday. What a treat. Delicious!
Linda Hawxhurst
Linda Hawxhurst
12:06 01 Sep 22
Had a last minute ceremony, Sugar Rush came through for us, decently priced lemon blueberry wedding cake with black drip, white wrap, and silver foil, and accents. Everybody loved it!! I HIGHLY recommend this place!!!! Thank you for making our day... extra special! Everybody was so kind to help us.read more
Josh Jennings
Josh Jennings
01:58 04 Oct 22
I just came there for the breakfast today. And wow! I got some croissant, a classic cinnamon roll and the apple cinnamon roll! Absolutely loved everything. The cinnamon rolls were delicious but too sweet for my own taste. My husband who is a sweets... lover absolutely adored and devoured it all! The croissant were my favorite! Sweet but not overly sweet. Can’t wait to return for more breakfast and normal everyday options! 10/10!!!!!read more
Shannon Foster
Shannon Foster
18:04 16 Aug 22
Great customer service! Great experience! Great cake! Everyone was so nice and helpful and they took my theme and ideas and ran with it. Loved the final product! Thank you.
Ryann Chaney
Ryann Chaney
11:58 25 Sep 22
Very yummy treats, and extremely friendly staff.
Sandi Martinez
Sandi Martinez
20:08 29 Jul 22
Wanted something to help with my sweets craving and found Sugar Rush through a quick Google search. I ordered the regular Birthday Cake milkshake to-go (Pro-Tip: bring a Tupperware container for the goodies on top so they make it home safely!).... Looking forward to trying to Cookies & Cream next time I stop in.read more
Heather Niccole
Heather Niccole
21:50 08 Sep 22
I found this place on tiktok and was amazed at the custom art work on the cakes. First we ordered cupcakes and cookies (I'm a crumbl snob and these cookies are way better here) to test them out and see if we liked them. Well we went back and ordered... a custom cake that did not disappoint! Not only was it gorgeous it was everything we wanted in a cake! We live an hour away and will be driving to get more cakes!!read more
Courtney Duncan
Courtney Duncan
23:24 10 Jun 22
Frank was a pleasure to work with and was able to make the wedding cake of our DREAMS! The process was easy and we got exactly what we wanted - not to mention the cake was absolutely delicious! The price is also extremely reasonable considering how... phenomenal their product is. Would certainly recommend Sugar Rush for all your Wedding (or any event) cake needs!read more
Abigail Okenge
Abigail Okenge
12:59 07 Sep 22
We’ve gotten all of our special event desserts from here. From our wedding cake to our baby shower cupcakes they never fail to impress. Always friendly with great service and fresh products. Churro is the best flavor by far!
Melissa Loth
Melissa Loth
19:37 30 May 22
Honestly the best cupcake I've had in a lonnnng time!! Everything looked so good I could have tried it all! Bonus points for the super nice employee who assisted me! 10/10
Courtney Shaw
Courtney Shaw
15:02 27 Aug 22
Definitely worth the stop while in Columbus! Service was awesome and let's talk about the sweet treats....WOW! We bought almost one if everything. It did not disappoint, so good!
Julie Willhauck
Julie Willhauck
00:35 23 May 22
I had one of there crazy shakes! It was amazing!! It was a milk shake with a iced cookie, iced cupcake, and a carmalized top marshmallow speared to the top of the shake with a huge straw! Try there baked good! They are excellent!!
Fred Stutske
Fred Stutske
18:32 24 Jul 22
I came here for the first time a few months back for a custom cake for my great niece. We were so impressed that I’ve been back for two more birthdays (once for another custom cake and once for cupcakes). The Buckeye cupcakes are amazing along with... everything else I’ve tried. I’ve found my new go to bakery. Mandy, Frank and staff are all a pleasure to work with!read more
Mandy Gischler
Mandy Gischler
18:22 02 May 22
Good cupcakes, brownies, cookies and most importantly the vibes!! This is a must try!
nika _xoxo
nika _xoxo
23:21 16 Jul 22
Staff was very friendly. Great shakes and sweets.
Jennifer Hartley
Jennifer Hartley
23:41 14 Apr 22
yum sugarvery tasty would recommendjosh is the best
will wood’s hat
will wood’s hat
22:37 06 Jul 22
Today was the first time I have personally purchased from Sugar Rush, but have had their cakes from a friend. I had a large order that reserved online (super easy process by the way) for cinnamon rolls. I did not realize how huge these things were... going to be! (Totally my bad, but they will get eaten!) I had a fairly large order with a bunch of cinnamon rolls, cupcakes, and cookies. I had my baby in the carseat and was somehow going to carry it all to the car, totally thinking multiple trips. The gentleman working there, that had taken care of me from start to finish, carried my stuff to my car. He was sooo amazing and sweet! I could not have had a better experience with them! Every single thing that I got was absolutely amazing!!!read more
Christy OPatik
Christy OPatik
01:20 20 Feb 22
Custom made cakes,on the high end $$.Delicious ! E Broad Reynoldsburg ,on the strip with Target.
Erica Taylor
Erica Taylor
17:02 21 Jun 22
I ordered a memorial cake for my daughters birthday. This was her 1st birthday in Heaven. They recommended a rainbow cake and they added 2 purple butterflies. Heathers favorite color was purple. The cake was amazing and so moist. The icing was... the best icing I have ever tasted! Again thank you so much for everything and taking the time to make this day special for her 10year old son Ayden and our family.read more
LaBrenda Gullett
LaBrenda Gullett
23:54 31 Jan 22
I called around town trying to find any baker to make a birthday cake with banana cake (not just frosting). Sugar Rush was the only baker that could!I also wanted the other half of the cake to be a yellow cake with all fillings to be a vanilla... custard.The end product was very interesting: a very tall 4-layer cake that was decorated very well. As promised the cake was delicious.The only negative was the filling on all levels was mostly chocolate cream with a scant amount of a vanilla that seemed more of a cream than a custard. It was disappointing as we didn't get the desired taste. So make sure to confirm and reconfirm your order as the recipt isn't enough. But overall I'd say it was a good cake. Next time I'd go with 2 two-layer cakes for ease of cutting and storage.read more
Wm Ao
Wm Ao
23:06 12 Jun 22
Sugar Rush did such a great job got my wedding! everything with so beautiful and tasty! they definitely did not disappoint! will be recommending them to anyone and everyone! they deserve all the hype!
Love this place they have the best dessert I’m addicted. They have huge cookies unique cupcakes and yummy macarons. They offer other treats but I haven’t tried them yet… guess I gotta go back soon? I’ll be sure to get the lemon blueberry and butter... beer cupcakes as well per usual lol. Those two are my favorites.read more
Joyce Lett
Joyce Lett
03:05 11 Jun 22
wow I can't say enough good things about this bakery and the people. The customer service too! The creme Brule cinnamon rolls are literally the BEST I've ever had! My family has tried almost everything in the store. I did a lot more shopping local... this year. This place we have hit monthly. my daughter took a cake class on early Decemner. She loved it! She said it was amazing fun and the lady was so nice and very passionate about baking.read more
Amy Carson
Amy Carson
12:26 25 Dec 21
This is such a delicious and fun bakery. The staff is amazing and will do anything custom. Whatever you can dream up. The cakes are so light and fluffy. Besides cakes, they have so much more to offer!! They also have baking camps for young ones... and they certainly make it magical and fun!!read more
Nicole Grosser
Nicole Grosser
22:59 07 Jun 22
We ordered a birthday cake for our twins and it was absolutely perfect!!!! The details were wonderful and it’s by far the best tasting Cale I’ve had locally!!!
Amy Thomas
Amy Thomas
19:28 17 Nov 21
Amazing customer services each and every time I visit! Oh did I mention how amazing the cookies and cupcakes are!
jean card
jean card
18:45 22 May 22
Love this place - staff are friendly, helpful and have wonderful customer service. I ordered Halloween Piñata cakes and we were really happy with our purchase. I would recommend and will definitely order from them again!
Siân Moran
Siân Moran
14:21 01 Nov 21
We ordered custom cupcakes for a birthday party. They turned out great! Highly recommend!
Collin Palmer
Collin Palmer
20:47 09 May 22
Sugar Rush Columbus is amazing! From the wonderful customer service to the amazing and delicious cake. So thankful I found you guys! Definitely worth the 40 minute drive.
Jenny Byers
Jenny Byers
13:47 26 Oct 21
Incredibly delicious and their cookies/cupcakes are a great price!I'm looking forward to ordering a cake from here in the future considering what I ordered was tasty. Their strawberry shortcake cookie was so delectable and not too overpowering with... the sweetness. However, if you do want sweet, their chocolate options were so tasty! Loved how patient the staff was as well while my mom and I took forever to look at their selection LOL but honestly, one of the best bakeries that I've been to! Trust me, I'm chubby so I know my sweets!!!read more
Kali Primp
Kali Primp
22:30 30 Apr 22
Sugar Rush Columbus went all out for my daughter’s 9th birthday party! We got the mini size and asked for a Hamilton the Musical theme. The cake was beautiful and tasted amazing! It was a pricier cake than we usually go for, but we got what we paid... for. If you need a show-stopper, this is the place to go!read more
Elizabeth Mattson
Elizabeth Mattson
11:31 24 Oct 21
Sugar Rush is the only place I go when my kids and I want some sweet treats. Mandy and Frank and the rest of the staff are always so helpful and always have a smile on their faces when you walk in the door. They really go above and beyond when... your order a specialty cake/cupcakes. Some other great qualities about Sugar Rush are they offer cake decorating classes and do activities for kids throughout the year. Plus they make sure they give back to the community. That’s pretty impressive if you ask me. So if you are looking for a specialty cake for your next birthday or event or just want a quick sweet treat, Sugar Rush is definitely the place to go.read more
Mom Miller
Mom Miller
13:33 24 Apr 22
My daughter and I had a great “girls day out” sharing a milkshake. The milkshake was delicious! I highly recommend!!
Erin Schwarz
Erin Schwarz
21:07 23 Oct 21
Love the milkshakes! Great local business.
Chase Ramsey
Chase Ramsey
13:25 24 Apr 22
Sugar Rush is an awesome bakery with a great staff. 100% would recommend a midday treat or a full birthday order!!
Adam Bale
Adam Bale
00:54 15 Oct 21
We absolutely love sugar rush!! We have purchased several different items and have never been disappointed. The staff has always been extremely nice and willing to help. I love having a local bakery for all my sweets needs!!
Sammi Martin
Sammi Martin
14:01 16 Apr 22
The cookies were amazing especially the chocolate mint one
Jill Burkart Brown
Jill Burkart Brown
18:52 12 Oct 21
**3/26/2022 EDITED TO ADD: Today we visited Sugar Rush to stock up on delicious goodies and to order a cake and goodies for my daughters upcoming birthday. Frank, who has helped my family many times, was beyond helpful and patient with us and very... friendly (he has the best “million dollar smile”!). He had great ideas/suggestions to add when discussing the details of the cake and cookies I was ordering. Frank is the definition of great customer service and Sugar Rush Columbus is lucky to have him on their team. Thank you for a pleasant experience, Frank and the Sugar Rush team!**Sugar Rush Columbus has become our “go-to” anytime we need sweet treats, whether it’s a birthday, anniversary, or just to celebrate that it’s Saturday and we survived another work-week. My daughter LOVES when I tell her we are going to visit “the bakery” (we seriously go 1 or 2 times a month) and is always eager to help me pick out whatever goodies are calling our name. Everytime we have visited, we have been warmly greeted and the staff are always so patient and friendly. I just wish we lived closer so we could visit every weekend!I am certain we have tried everything offered at least once- The cakes and cupcakes are amazing, the mash-up cookies are always a fun treat, the milkshakes are a tasty adventure, but my favorite thing to get (and my daughters’) are the hot cocoa-bombs. Seriously, you won’t go wrong with anything you pick from Sugar Rush. 10/10 recommend, hands down!read more
Amy Armstead
Amy Armstead
00:57 27 Mar 22
We had the most amazing wedding cake made by sugar rush! Each of our tiers was a different flavor & our wedding guest loved it!
Samantha Forsythe
Samantha Forsythe
22:31 10 Oct 21
They are amazing. They volunteered to make my sons birthday cake when he was diagnosed with cancer 2021 free of charge .I wasn’t expecting the cake to be 2 tier, and look and taste amazing as it did. I now stop by for cupcakes and cakes and plan to... order more birthday cakes .read more
B'Raww Bxtch
B'Raww Bxtch
00:04 05 Mar 22
This bakery is the best in town. It has wonderful cupcakes, cakes, cookies, and more. Everything is so fresh and tasty. The staff are incredible. I love this place.
Suzette Michelle King
Suzette Michelle King
21:11 10 Oct 21
Sugar Rush is TOP NOTCH. Every time I visit I’m welcomed with a positive attitude by every employee and get some of the BEST treats. So far the S’mores Cookies and their Cinnamon Rolls are my favorite!
Hayley Jones
Hayley Jones
23:58 04 Mar 22
Great spot to stop by to grab dessert for the family!
Melissa Marie
Melissa Marie
20:25 10 Oct 21
I don't usually leave reviews. But OMG! My daughters 1st bday cake looked fabulous and EXACTLY how I pictured it to look. Also, it smelled soooooooo good in there! This is my first time ever being here or had ever heard of Sugar Rush. LET ME TELL... YOU! If you're someone like me, who is a free soul and loves weirdness and all that, then walking in here will MEZMORIZE you! As soon as I walked in though, not gonna lie, I felt like I had walked into a tattoo shop lol. That IS NOT a bad thing.read more
Gabby Campbell
Gabby Campbell
18:48 22 Jan 22
We love SugarRush! The mashup cookies are huge and amazing. They always have a large selection. Pictured is at be s’more mashup and the butter beer cupcake
Susie Fleming
Susie Fleming
20:22 10 Oct 21
I’ve been following this bakery on Instagram for a while now and finally decided to check it out. I picked up a creme brûlée and a s’mores cookie. They were delicious. I need to try their other items too!
R B
R B
15:51 13 Nov 21
The people at Sugar Rush are absolutely amazing! We ordered a cake and the day before pick up our son was hospitalized. The staff was so understanding and put our order on hold until we were able to reschedule our party. The cake was definitely... worth the wait, as it was delicious and beautiful, exactly what our daughter asked for.read more
Austie McDonald
Austie McDonald
02:42 19 Sep 21
Wow! The ice reams and cookies and cakepops and cup cakes are delicious
kathy milburn
kathy milburn
19:00 29 Dec 22
Love the variety of cupcakes and trying new flavors each time! Cookies and cake pops are great too. Always friendly service
Alexis Von Pletz
Alexis Von Pletz
00:04 07 Aug 21
We have loved everything we have gotten. Great quality and presentation. My boys and I highly recommend Sugar Rush to others!
In need of a cake, ASAP, Mandy did her work and not only made me a cake but used a color in the icing that the birthday girl likes and made edible flowers that were just beautiful. The cake was one of the best I’ve ever had (Choc-fudge)!!!!...

This is the best bakery around!!!
Thanks you guys for all you do!!!

I’ll be back!!!
read more
Diane Wagner
Diane Wagner
19:07 30 Jul 21
Great people and great cupcakes we will definitely be back!
Aaron Rick
Aaron Rick
17:17 25 Nov 22
Sugar Rush has the most unique sweets! The cake pops were a hit! Thank you Sugar Rush
Garnet Fisher
Garnet Fisher
18:19 29 Jul 21
I just have to let everyone know that this was literally the best cake I have ever eaten!!!! Not only was the design a work of art but tasted out of this world! It was so good. The first tier was orange dreamsicle, the second tier raspberry and the... third tier strawberry lemonade. This cake was the talk of the party. Ordering was super easy. Craig was super cool and very professional. He made suggestions that took this cake to another level. Thank you so much Sugar Rush for an amazing experience. Y’all will not be disappointed in ordering your cakes from them. I’m Sugar Rush fanatic!read more
Mashellee Lee
Mashellee Lee
00:17 06 Nov 22
Christmas in July! This was our first time coming to Sugar Rush. You didn’t disappoint! The staff is friendly and the ice cream and toppings….delicious!!!!! Great atmosphere and delicious ice cream shakes!
Colleen Moore
Colleen Moore
20:13 24 Jul 21
I found Sugar Rush when looking for custom gourmet cupcakes for my daughter's 16th birthday to take to her volleyball team. Each player picked out their specific flavor, it was a HIT and talked about for weeks.....actually a year later because they... requested the cupcakes again, haha! And yes, they were purchased again!! We've also had custom cakes made for our families annual Gingerbread House Decorating contest, this year will be the 2nd annual cake for our 2nd annual contest. Everything Mandy and her team create in their shop is absolutely delicious......mash-up cookies.....wow, to die for!read more
Stacie Meeks
Stacie Meeks
14:44 04 Nov 22
I ordered a cake and cupcakes for a surprise 50th party. When I arrived to pick them up something went wrong and they did not have my order. I stressed out, but Frank told me that they would make the cake and bring it to my party. He arrived with... exactly what I had ordered and the cake and cupcakes were so good! They went above and beyond to get me my cake. I would recommend Sugar Rush 1,000 times!!read more
Erica Marino
Erica Marino
14:43 11 Jul 21
Hands down the best! Such a great variety of flavors and themes! Our favorite place.
ashton orton
ashton orton
11:07 04 Nov 22
Took the family there today and we got cosmic brownie cookies, cake popsicles, choc chip cookies, and buckeye cookies. They are HUGE, moist, delicious. By far these are the best cookies in the world. Next time we will try the milkshakes and... cupcakes. Frank and his staff were patient with my kiddos taking forever and asking about every (literally) item on display including the coffee, candles, and decorations.read more
Lauren Anne
Lauren Anne
00:08 08 Jul 21
AMAZING-😍 I ordered smashup cookies from sugar rush Columbus and had them shipped from Ohio to Texas.. I ordered them and the were shipped on Tuesday and received them on Thursday . The cookies were all in one piece and each one was securely... wrapped. They were so fresh and the flavor of each cookie is amazing. One cookie is enough for 4 people to share. If you are looking for an amazing Christmas or birthday gift to ship to a a friend or loved one,This would definitely be a wonderful gift. The cookies not only look great and Nicely packaged. They are the best cookies I have ever e tasted. LOVE SUGAR RUSH ❤️read more
Darla Donahue
Darla Donahue
11:50 01 Oct 22
Got cupcakes for a graduation party a few weekends back and there was a little hiccup but they were absolutely amazing in making things right and the cupcakes were phenomenal. 10/10 recommend to anyone and will be returning for future parties!
Dani Stanley
Dani Stanley
16:25 30 Jun 21
Amazing cake!! I'm kind of cheap guy, so I felt like my cake was on the pricey side. Boy was I wrong. Our experience was totally worth it. Customer service and the cake was awesome! I'll be getting birthday cakes for the family from here on out.... SERIOUSLY!read more
Demond Ford
Demond Ford
13:57 07 Sep 22
Been here several times and we are NEVER disappointed!
While picking up our usual half dozen killer cupcakes today we also grabbed a milkshake for our son and that masterpiece deserved a gold medal 🤩
Kelly Allen Arnold
Kelly Allen Arnold
01:39 17 Jun 21
They have the best customer service in the business, this is a place I definitely recommend you check them out for any occasion. SUGAR RUSH ROCKS!
Wayne Logan
Wayne Logan
19:53 29 Jul 22
The chocolate covered strawberries are the bomb.
Andrea Francesco Como
Andrea Francesco Como
16:00 03 Jun 21
Most delicious place in Columbus!
Alicia Westforth
Alicia Westforth
18:15 07 Jul 22
Thank you thank you thank you!!! Everything you made for Judah’s first birthday was absolute perfection!!! Thank you for helping a mama create her dream party for her 🌈
Nicci Tierney
Nicci Tierney
02:57 30 May 21
The cookies are delicious, we love the flavor variety!
Sophie Fitzhugh
Sophie Fitzhugh
00:28 17 Jun 22
Excellent staff and wonderful environment. If you haven't tried them...TRY. Try them all. My personal favorite is the cheesecake and the samoa.
Heavenly Host
Heavenly Host
21:34 18 May 21
Great cupcakes
Chris Walden
Chris Walden
01:33 08 Jun 22
Stopped in this morning for some treats. We just ate our cupcakes, and I absolutely loved the apple pie one and the banana one (Elvis cupcake). I should have gotten more of those two! Will most definitely be back!
April Lowry
April Lowry
21:55 09 May 21
I went to Sugar Rush a couple weeks ago to order a cake for my parents’ 60th birthday party. I’d been a few times just to get some sweet treats like cupcakes and cake pops (which are delicious) and didn’t realize I could have placed my cake order... online. Frank, the manager, was extremely gracious and took my order on short notice. The cake turned out better than I imagined. Many of the party guests commented on how pretty the cake was, but also how absolutely delicious it was! I ordered a salted caramel and chocolate cake w/ vanilla buttercream frosting. What a delicious combo!I cannot say enough good things about this establishment, and the people who work there. You helped make my parents’ birthday that more special and I’m so grateful! This is certainly a hidden gem on the east side of town that I hope doesn’t stay a secret for too long.read more
Kelsey Gregory
Kelsey Gregory
22:05 09 May 22
Love this place! I have been ordering since this sweet lady was baking out of Sextons pizza! So glad she has a place like this where we all get to enjoy her talents!
Laci Wilson
Laci Wilson
00:45 17 Apr 21
Without a doubt they have the best sweets in all of Columbus! They’re always coming out with new ideas for cupcake flavors and everyone here is so friendly. My personal favorite is the churro cupcake that has a mini churro on top! If you have a... sweet tooth, sugar rush is perfect for you!read more
Dylan Walker
Dylan Walker
15:56 24 Apr 22
My kids and I love this place!! Their cupcakes are amazing!
Marie Smith
Marie Smith
00:32 03 Apr 21
This place is awesome. We had a cake made by frank and it was absolutely amazing! It was for my brother’s 3rd birthday! It looked great and the taste made it 100 times better! The price was reasonable as well for how good it looked! If you want a... nice cake I recommend coming here!read more
gia princess
gia princess
23:26 17 Apr 22
Friendly staff and a variety of delectable treats.
Hillary Davis
Hillary Davis
19:35 20 Feb 21
Amazing buckeye cupcake!! YUM!!
Susan Lynn
Susan Lynn
21:00 15 Mar 22
Beautiful product, great presentation, good prices, quick turnaround, and clear communications with orders.
Sean Michael
Sean Michael
17:42 12 Feb 21
I buy Cakes and Cookies. My Favorite is the Campfire Cookie. It is absolutely delicious like everything else they have.
Brandy Cain
Brandy Cain
19:27 24 Jan 22
this place is absolutely amazing! the very berry cupcake was the best cupcake I've had in a very long time! and the cakesicle was yummmm tooooo
Sondra Lee
Sondra Lee
02:01 16 Jan 21
Sugar Rush did an amazing job on the cake for my daughter’s 9th birthday! It looked and tasted amazing. We got the mini sized, but there was nothing “mini” about it. It was pricier than what we usually get for a kids party, but well worth the... cost. Go here if you need a real show-stopper!read more
Elizabeth Mattson
Elizabeth Mattson
02:12 01 Nov 21
We went to a cake decorating class last night. My daughter and I had a great time and came home with gorgeous cakes!
Keith Witt
Keith Witt
15:08 12 Jan 21
I bought a death by chocolate cake for my dad for his 90th birthday, it exceeded my expectations, moist, so delicious 😋
Gail Simmerman
Gail Simmerman
14:28 30 Nov 22
So I’ve known the head baker, Mandy for about 3-4 years (give or take). I was her one of her son’s PreK teachers and she used to bring us the most HEAVENLY brownies that I have ever tasted! So when i saw that she was opening her own bakery i got... super excited.

I went in yesterday and it is so beautiful and colorful and has a cozy feeling that you only get from local type restaurants. I got cupcakes & the taco desserts (idk what they are technically called 🥴). Everything was SO DELICIOUS but those cupcakes......i can’t even lie, i ate half the pack as soon as i got home! The flavor combinations were incredible, the cupcake itself was so soft and moist and the icing/decorations were so beautiful. The taco creations were out of this world delicious and not too sweet but just enough sweetness to satisfy.

I would highly recommend Sugar Rush Columbus for any and all of your baking desires and I am definitely coming back soon. Congratulations to you Mandy for a job well done ❤️
read more
Eugene Hinton
Eugene Hinton
17:38 03 Jan 21
A wonderful family-owned business with great customer service! Greeted with a smile upon arrival and the staff was very very helpful! Such a unique place with unique items that are not only very tasty but very affordable. I recommend this place to... anyone looking for Custom Cakes or just to satisfy a sugar craving!read more
Randy Gillespie
Randy Gillespie
22:13 04 Nov 22
The cupcakes are delicious and the owners/staff are extremely nice!!! 😃
Lauren Ammon
Lauren Ammon
21:54 29 Dec 20
Our daughter recently turned 10 and specifically requested a Cookies and Cream cake. Remembering we had recently had Sugar Rush cupcakes at a friend's party, I hopped online and happily saw they make one as part of their regular inventory. We popped... in on a Saturday and purchased the cake and some random cupcakes. Everything was delicious and we will definitely be back!read more
Desiree Johnson
Desiree Johnson
20:06 11 Oct 22
I am just amazed! The customer service, the cleanliness, the yummy sweets 🥰 🧁🍭🍰 we loved it all! Definitely coming back for more 🥰
1st time yesterday. Delicious!
Linda Hawxhurst
Linda Hawxhurst
12:00 01 Sep 22
I love sugar rush! First time ordering a cake from here, did it all in messages, advance Pay all I went to do is pick it up no hassle worth the drive, and my son’s reaction was priceless. Cake was chocolate and vanilla so delicious will be ordering... againread more
Mari Morales
Mari Morales
13:34 08 Dec 20
We had a great experience for our wedding cake. Sugar Rush was professional, flexible, and responsive throughout the entire planning process.
Colleen Spangler
Colleen Spangler
04:21 27 Jun 22
What a great place! Wonderful cupcakes and they do beautiful cakes.
Ryan C. Strategier
Ryan C. Strategier
04:53 25 Nov 20
If you want a cake that tastes great and has excellent quality-This Is Your Place to Eat and Order Out!I have purchased 3 cakes now, and every time they have came out perfect. The texture is realistic, and the moisture inside the cake is... heavenly. I have also purchased cookies during the holidays which was a blast decorating with my son.The custom process was simple. I ordered on-line, and then had someone from their service staff confirm the details for my special cake. They also confirmed my arrival time before I needed to pick up my cake.I highly recommend!read more
Sonya Sexton
Sonya Sexton
18:11 02 Jun 22
We sampled many treats the night before the grand opening. They were gracious enough to pack everything to go (COVID and all) and it was all delicious!
Amanda Dlugiewicz Lee
Amanda Dlugiewicz Lee
16:50 21 Nov 20
The service is great and everything we have tried from there desert wise was absolutely amazing. Can't wait to try to again.
Wes Cochran
Wes Cochran
13:27 24 Apr 22
Picked up a mystery sample box on their grand opening day! Everything looks absolutely delicious and everyone was SO kind!
Ariana Waites
Ariana Waites
16:28 21 Nov 20
Hands down THE BESSSST Peanut Butter Milkshake I’ve ever had !!! Will definitely go again. Thank you Sugar Rush 😋
Jules Clark
Jules Clark
23:59 04 Mar 22
The Creme Brulee cookies were to die for. The actual cookie was fantastic but the torched icing on top was AMAZING. I can't wait to order other items, worth the drive from Hilliard!
Siera Marie Hayes
Siera Marie Hayes
17:14 29 Oct 20
We ordered a birthday cake for my sons 1st birthday! The customer service was exceptional! My sons theme was time flies and I sent them reference photos and discussed the cake over the phone. I had exactly what I wanted in my mind and they came... through with exactly what I was thinking! The entire experience was perfect and I was over the moon with this cake. The taste was amazing. My son loved every bit of his smash cake and I will continue to use them for the future.read more
Sierra Parsons
Sierra Parsons
01:23 12 Dec 22
Sugar Rush Columbus made my cake and cupcakes for my wedding. They were so easy to work with and absolutely delicious. We had so many compliments on how good all 4 of the flavors were. I highly recommend them!!
Nicole Evans
Nicole Evans
23:55 05 Oct 20
We use Sugar Rush quite often and love all of the amazing cakes and cupcakes we get! Love the family that works and owns the business.
Lori Chuang
Lori Chuang
12:03 04 Nov 22
Bought the Lemon Blueberry cake during a quick sale. It had REAL BLUEBERRIES!!! This cake was so yummy! Moist! Definitely can’t wait til the store opens to get my cake on!!
Annie Hoh Seaton
Annie Hoh Seaton
18:24 24 Sep 20
Not only do they have delicious, flavorful cupcakes and cookies, all with their own unique twists. They have these amazing extreme milkshakes i stumbled across today. If you want to know how good they are, I bought one to-go too!! But hey, don't... take my word for it, go try it yourself, you won't be disappointed!!read more
Hannah Cohen
Hannah Cohen
19:00 21 Jul 22
Don’t even know where to begin to thank the amazing team at Sugar Rush for the most incredible cake. Moving to Columbus from Los Angeles at the beginning of COVID we had to unfortunately let go of our cake topper and so for our 1st anniversary we... didn’t get to enjoy it. Needless to say, I was SUPER bummed. We’d yet to find a bakery that we loved here...and then came Sugar Rush. Super easy and fast ordering process, a breeze to safely pickup (welcome treat in COVID times) but still I was skeptical because in my experience either decoration is amazing or cake is. Boy was I proven wrong. A gorgeous cake that was even more yummy than it was beautiful. REAL buttery creamy frosting (not the overly sugary kind) and moist flavorful REAL tasting cake. Not too much sweetness but just enough to give u that SUGAR RUSH...The Nutella ROCKS and we cannot wait to try the other fun flavors. We’ll be clients for life and cannot recommend the staff or their treats more highly. Can’t wait for the storefront to open! We’ll be bringing the SUGAR RUSH to every big and small event we can!! 💕🎂🤤🥰read more
This is my second review but I just had to post another. Thus was by far the best cake ever created. It was so beautiful and the detail was on point. They took my ideas of my son’s graduation cake to the next level. Not to mention it was delicious... as well as gorgeous. I highly recommend them for any cake idea or just wanting something sweet. Thank you Sugar Rush for making the day complete.read more
L.M. Stanford
L.M. Stanford
16:41 08 May 22
Very professional and did everything I asked for on the cake I love her work ! The cake was perfect and tasted delicious ❤️
Zeynab Omar
Zeynab Omar
16:46 23 Aug 20
My husband and I got married on Halloween this year and we went to sugar rush to get the cake of our dreams. I just want to say that their team did an absolutely amazing job answering all of our questions and bringing our vision to life. Frank is... probably kindest soul you’ll meet and I highly encourage stopping in for a sweet treat at-least once. I waited to share a review as I wanted to have the best photos of the cake possible. Thank you again so much for taking such good care of us!read more
Sammie Pruitt
Sammie Pruitt
16:08 17 Nov 21
Sugar Rush made this cake for my dads 37th birthday & it turned out great! Everyone loved it I’ll definitely order from them again in the future!
Hannah Kelly
Hannah Kelly
02:54 06 Aug 20
I ordered a custom cake for my husbands 60th birthday. From the creative brainstorming to the follow to the actual cake Sugar Rush was the star of the night. The price was affordable for the professional and creative touches. The flavors were... unbelievable! Thank you for making my husbands cake!! Fred &Monica Hartread more
Moni H (Moni)
Moni H (Moni)
14:14 24 Sep 22
Awesome experience and delicious! I ordered cake pops and macaroons for our daughter’s graduation party. They flew off the table! I should have ordered double. Everyone was talking about how delicious they were and asking where I got them. They were... beautifully decorated as well. Highly recommend! Huge variety of flavors also. I will definitely be ordering more.read more
Lisa Renner Gunter
Lisa Renner Gunter
02:14 04 Aug 20
My baby shower was on Sunday, I originally planned on having a home baker make my cake, and cake pops but they canceled on me the day before my shower. I found sugar rush and called them immediately. They squeezed in time to make me the most... beautiful cake and cake pops with only a day notice! Definitely will be calling them to make any other cake I need in the future!read more
Kali Arruda
Kali Arruda
17:31 30 Mar 22
We were able to celebrate our 2020 LH graduate today, and we ordered a cake from sugar rush. I’m so glad we did! It was perfect. We couldn’t of asked for anything more. It was also soooo delicious! We will definitely order again for future... events!! Thank you for helping make today special for our daughter!read more
Michelle Busker
Michelle Busker
01:58 27 Jul 20
Exceeded our expectations from decor to taste! Cake was moist and the raspberry filling was delicious. Excellent customer service and great shop to support!
Ashley Koh
Ashley Koh
16:14 11 Jun 22
We recently had Sugar Rush make our husbands 50th Birthday cake. Not only did they knock it out of the park worth making a Coors Light cake, in a perfect bottle I miss say with labels and all, but made his birthday extra special. Also highly... recommend the Red Velvet Cake.. Amazing.. Highly recommended!!!!read more
Ginni Stillion May
Ginni Stillion May
00:13 22 Jul 20
I’m always satisfied when I pick up a birthday cake, cupcakes or other treats for the kids. It’s always clean and I receive top notch service! Their custom cakes are amazing, I can’t wait to get in and have a milkshake!
jeremiah wilkes
jeremiah wilkes
14:37 06 Nov 22
Ordered cake, cupcakes and cake pops for our grad party... five different flavors and all were amazing! Everything completely surpassed all expectations. I even have an icing snob or two in the family and even they loved everything they tried. ... Will definitely make this our go to cake place from now on.read more
Kathy Queen
Kathy Queen
21:35 12 Jul 20
Sugar Rush Columbus did a cake for my 30th birthday. I was looking for a specific custom cake and I’m so glad I found them to make it because they knocked it out of the park! And it wasn’t only pretty, it tasted soooooo good.
Alissa Friece
Alissa Friece
17:10 12 Jul 20
We ordered a 16th Birthday tie-dye cake and she really delivered. Not only did it look amazing, but tasted amazing too!
My daughter wanted a Hawaiian themed cake and SRC made the absolute most beautiful & delicious pineapple upside down cake for her 11th bday. The process was super simple and the cake was beyond our expectations! Thank you!!!
Sarah Sutton
Sarah Sutton
09:09 01 Jul 20
Responsive and friendly! I was able to provide a picture of what I was looking for and was definitely delivered. I was happy to see the convenient payment options and easy pick up. The cake and cupcakes we ordered were great quality, the edible... pieces and glitter were a very nice touch for the theme of our party. The taste and texture of what we ordered was a huge hit with party guests. We will order again for our next event 🥳read more
Kaitlyn Marisa
Kaitlyn Marisa
16:09 28 Jun 20
My daughter loved her Octonauts Cake and it was delicious! I loved that she had toys to play with afterwards too! Good communication and cake was done in the time promised. I would definitely recommend and will do business with Sugar Rush again!
Vanessa Cooper
Vanessa Cooper
20:27 18 Jun 20
I ordered the Crown Royal Apple cake for delivery and was not disappointed. It was a great experience from start to finish and the responses to my questions was quick. The cake was delicious. I had requested delivery and was informed on the day it... was to be delivered that it would be a little late. I was fine with that and it arrived within the timeframe stated. It was a great experience all the way around. I highly recommend Sugar Rush Columbus.read more
Joan Epstein
Joan Epstein
15:38 17 Jun 20
Best surprise cake ever! My husband was so shocked and said he’d never seen anything like it! Delicious and I would totally recommend this shop for cakes!! Thank you so much for such a special day!! We will definitely be ordering more!!
Amanda Woosley
Amanda Woosley
22:22 16 Jun 20
Our ice cream themed cake was perfect! I showed her a picture of what we wanted and she made it happen. We chose the strawberry crunch flavor... let me tell you... sooooo sooo delish! My daughter loved it all. We will definitely be keeping Sugar... Rush on our list and recommending them to everyone. Best part of it all, they are so flexible and work with you. I could not come out during pick up times and they made every effort to make it possible for us, even delivering it right to our doorstep. Please don’t even hesitate on your decision to order. Trust Sugar Rush! Thanks again Sugar Rush for an amazing cake!read more
Deborah Dill
Deborah Dill
16:31 14 Jun 20
Oh my goodness, thank you so much. I am such a cake snob...so much so that 1. I never waste money on bakery cakes bc I cant find a good one anywhere, and 2. Ive had this pregnancy craving for a good cake for 6 months now with no option to fill it. ... Your cake was exactly what I've been looking for! SO delicious, perfect flavor, and super moist!! Seriously! Thank you thank you thank you!! craving finally satisfied (except now Im going to start craving YOUR cakes 😉)read more
Natalie King
Natalie King
18:43 07 Jun 20
This was my first time ordering a cake from here and their service, promptness, communication and execution of the cake design I wanted was on point from start to finish. I was very nervous of how it would turn out because I have had ‘not so good’... experiences with other cake orders in the past. The cake looked amazing, tasted great and you guys really make the birthday girl smile. I will recommend Sugar Rush to others and I will be back for any of my future baking needs.read more
Kirstie Wilson
Kirstie Wilson
12:47 30 May 20
Just got a cake from here today! It was even better than I expected visually. Then I got home cut the cake the icing is not hard at all! And it was a hit from everyone here! So happy I tried it. You’re amazing, we will be forever customers.
Essence Ashanti
Essence Ashanti
01:57 29 May 20
We got a smash cake for our one year old and two dozen mini cupcakes, they were all fantastic! Not only did they look great but they tasted even better! Ordering was so easy and pick up was just as smooth! Will definitely order again for next family... birthday, thank you so much @sugarrushcolumbusread more
Nicole Capretta
Nicole Capretta
13:06 24 May 20
absolutely amazing from the cakes to the cake pops to the cookies. some of the most amazing baked goods I've ever had.
Dirk FA Mason
Dirk FA Mason
23:35 20 May 20
Ordered my daughters birthday cake... It was beautifully decorated..was the most delicious and moist cake I ever tasted...all of my expectations were met .. From the decorations to the taste of the cake.. even the service was wonderful!!Also... cupcakes are amazing too!! Even during the covid-19 Sugar Rush was able to make pick up easy and safe (curbside pick up). Highly recommend!!read more
Erika Jo
Erika Jo
16:36 06 May 20
1. The creative team at Sugar Rush is second to none. Not only will Amanda bring your ideas to life, she will also provide recommendations to make your unique piece really “pop”. That extra level of customer service IS the difference between a... good finished product and an exceptional one.

2. The leadership team at Sugar Rush are perfectionists (and it shows in every aspect of the process), from the pre-order design consultations to the final presentation, they go above and beyond to ensure an A+ product and experience.

3. Professionalism and Customer Service are extraordinary (see bullet points 1 & 2)
read more
Joe Butler
Joe Butler
00:04 06 May 20
Amanda was amazing to work with! She gave me great suggestions and awesome service! Her cupcakes 🧁 are moist and the icing is wonderful! We also had her cake pops and meringue treats. These were decorated very nicely and very tasty! I’m... excited to use her again for all my desserts !read more
Sandy Wernick Wylie
Sandy Wernick Wylie
23:36 30 Apr 20
I have ordered two cakes from Sugar Rush. The cakes taste amazing and she provides great service. She is my number one choice when it comes to selecting personalized cakes for my friends and family! Thank you!!!
Constance Harvey
Constance Harvey
13:59 29 Apr 20
We ordered our first cake from Sugar Rush for my daughters 4th birthday party. I was very impressed, it was very good and looked amazing! Will definitely be ordering again soon!
Jasmine Clemens
Jasmine Clemens
23:17 28 Apr 20
The brownies and icing were AMAZING! 1,000% recommend!
Sara Feldman
Sara Feldman
00:14 26 Apr 20
I absolutely love Sugar Rush! Service was amazing! And the cake was the best I’ve had! It’s was so moist and delicious and not too sweet. Can’t wait to order again and try something different!
Jessica Rose
Jessica Rose
02:12 21 Apr 20
I ordered the mani/pedi cupcake package. They were delivered by a very nice young man. My granddaughter was soooo excited. She followed the directions and had the best time decorating the cupcakes. They were delicious!!! Fresh and moist. I will be... forever ordering any sweets possible from this incredible company!!! I would recommend sugar rush to anyone!!!
Thank you so much for brightening our day🌻
read more
Beverly Dorminy Young
Beverly Dorminy Young
12:50 16 Apr 20
I am so excited I found you!! From cookies to brownies and now cake! Sugar Rush has the perfect blend between cake & icing. It’s ok to have more then one slice, you won’t feel guilty! Easy to order & pick up...totally worth every penny! Keep doing... what your doing! It’s working!!read more
We ordered baby shark sugar cookies for my daughters 2nd birthday and they were amazing!! They were perfect for her theme and she loved them! Thank you so much
Krystal Fifer
Krystal Fifer
23:46 13 Apr 20
Amazing cake in looks and taste! Mandy was great to work with and the delivery was perfect!
Jill Armstrong
Jill Armstrong
23:11 12 Apr 20
We ordered a donut drip cake from Sugar Rush and it was amazing! Beautiful cake, tasted great! My daughter loved it so much she didnt want to cut into it to eat! We will definitely be ordering our future cakes from Mandy!
Nicole Adler
Nicole Adler
15:46 04 Apr 20
Love, love, love the DIY kits! They are a fun activity for the grandkids, and it brings a smile to their faces. I've been told it's all delicious, and I look forward to participating in the DIY party as soon as the stay at home order is over. ... Thank you Sugar Rush for the fun edible activityread more
Angela D'Andrea-Raye
Angela D'Andrea-Raye
15:08 03 Apr 20
Thank you so much for the beautiful cake! My husband loved it and it was delicious!!
Maria Bairamis Belak
Maria Bairamis Belak
00:31 31 Mar 20
I ordered two brownie boxes and a dozen cookies to decorate for my son's birthday they were absolutely a hit delicious fun and inexpensive we will definitely order again and recommend everyone join in 😁❤️
Irene Renie
Irene Renie
15:18 22 Mar 20
I ordered a brownie box with vanilla buttercream and peanut butter buttercream and it was delicious. The brownies were moist and the pb buttercream was the perfect match! And, the best part was that I didn’t have to do any dishes afterwards. Thanks... Sugar Rush!!read more
Brandi Meeker Burns
Brandi Meeker Burns
21:45 29 Feb 20
js_loader