Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes
Custom Order Cakes

We are here to help make your special day stand out!

Place Your Custom Order

You can count on Sugar Rush Columbus for your custom treats!

Our Wedding Cakes are featured in The Knot  and in Wedding Wire

Who doesn’t like a fresh made cookie?

Sugar Rush Columbus offers many different cookies for pickup, eat in or local delivery (delivery charge extra). You may choose to have a select few of our amazing cookies to be shipped nationally! Alaska and Hawaii not included. Send that perfect gift to someone in your life to let them know how lucky you are to know them.

Because of the nature of our cookies and Sugar Rush Columbus wanting you to receive the best product available, certain cookies are only available locally. The cookies available for national shipping are as follows: The OG, Peanut butter Overload, Smores, Jumbo M&M, cookies and cream, Cookie Monster, Somewhere Over the Rainbow, Megadoodle, Oh My Buckeye, and cookie confusion.

Customer Reviews

Cup cakes were good
When I contacted Dr Eseigbe, He told me Everything I needed to do and I did & he helped me cast a Love Spell and within 15hrs My Lover came back to me and started apologizing, now he has stopped going out with girls and he is with me for good and for real. Contact this Great spell Caster for your relationship or marriage problem via WhatsApp at +2349069550262. Or contact him via his Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/Dr-Eseigbe-love-spell-caster-102398365076297/
These guys did such an amazing job! I need last minute, custom cake pops for my sister's baby shower. My other sister had a vision and wanted them to look like flowers popping up in a garden. They looked perfect and tasted so good. We added crushed oreos for dirt and some gummy worms. Otherwise, they did everything else and they turned out exactly as we wanted. Highly recommend this place!
I personally don't even like cake .
I attended a graduation party in 2023 where they served a Sugar Rush cake ,I took a small slice home to be polite 🤦‍♀️one bite and I'm messaging the hostess asking where did you get that cake ...I've been hooked ever since .I've bought thier quick cakes and done custom orders neither have disappointed.
I highly recommend !
This place is amazing been there a few times always great service amazing ppl and just all around amazing and the treats r to die for! If yall ain't been deff give them a try!
The only way I could describe these delicacies are extremely rich very very tasty. The first time I walked in Mandy, the owner, Was extremely welcoming and knowledgeable. If you are looking for these type of delicacies I suggest you try Is Mandy's Treats. You will not regret it!!!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for the kind review, Joe! It was such a pleasure meeting you and your wife. We hope to see you both back in the shop again soon! -Mandy
Best customer service ever! I’ve had two cakes from here and several sets of cupcakes in store and DoorDash and it’s always amazing. I will not go anywhere else for birthday cakes.
I love the cupcakes here. I always get them for little treats or birthdays. They are probably the best cupcakes I have ever had
I got my son's 16th birthday here. It was my first time buying a cake from here. I would definitely recommend them. I got two cakes one looked like a Oreo Cookie and the second a Oreo themed cake. They were both really good tasting and both very nice looking.
When I walked on the door, I was treated with kindness laughter and so much respect from the Owners. The cookies was huge and Delicious. Yes I will definitely come back Strawberry Cheesecake cookies was my favorite 😍
I LOVE Sugar Rush. I have two daughters that always want custom cakes for their birthdays. I made them for the first six years but now the cake wants are so difficult I had to find a bakery. We’ve gotten two birthday cakes here so far and they have been so beautiful and tasty. We’ve also grabbed sweets from here whenever I have a sweet tooth and absolutely everything has been amazing. The process is very simple for ordering a cake, everyone I spoke to was so nice, and the quality is amazing. I’m even thinking about splurging on my own birthday cake this year from here!
The best desserts for adult sweet tooths and the cutest cookies for kids! 10/10 recommend from our family!
I highly recommend this bakery. I ordered a Valentine’s Day cake and it did not disappoint. It was perfect!
Delicious bakery! My family loves Sugar Rush. We go in and order through Door Dash sometimes. It is a fun atmosphere and the staff is always really pleasant and patient when we take 100 years picking things out.
We got six different flavors of cupcakes and the Dubai chocolate bar and enjoyed everything! Pick up was quick and staff were friendly! We will order from here again!
Quick withdrawals without being charged a fee and a top-notch trading platform. Everything is excellent. I have been trading with this broker for a few months and so far all seems consistently well. I like this company. I like the fact that they are reliable. I find them reliable and professional. Mr. Killian Bayer is one of my all-time favorites. he replies promptly and most importantly in the right manner. I feel confident trading with he platform and I can rely on this company to succeed in my trades. he has given me great opportunities to earn money. I am glad to have traded with the right brokerage platform. I gain good profit and received my withdrawals earlier.
Words can express how grateful I am Mr. KILLIAN BAYER
Contact him via
WhatsApp: +1 (707) 654-4150
Email: killianbayer704@gmail.com
FB: Killian Bayer
Ordered a 3-tier 50th anniversary cake for our friends' 50th anniversary party to match their traditional style wedding cake with a modern flair. The cake not only was stunning but was delicious. So many people commented on the cake. It truly was spectacular. I've never had a more delicious white cake and yummy buttercream frosting ever. Highly recommend Sugar Rush.
The best cake in Columbus!
Their monster cookies are fantastic! I love sweets and their cookies are always fresh and delicious.
We ordered a birthday cake for my sons 1st birthday! The customer service was exceptional! My sons theme was time flies and I sent them reference photos and discussed the cake over the phone. I had exactly what I wanted in my mind and they came through with exactly what I was thinking! The entire experience was perfect and I was over the moon with this cake. The taste was amazing. My son loved every bit of his smash cake and I will continue to use them for the future.
We have taken several cake and cookie decorating classes, stopped in and gotten treats on a random day and have NEVER had a bad experience.

Service is always prompt, kind, and offers great suggestions!

I will continue using Sugar Rush as our bakery destination and continuously recommend them to others!
Delicious unique treats and cakes with the best buttercream I've ever had!
This is one of my favorite bakeries in town! We’ve ordered 3 custom cakes and today I went in to grab a ready made cake and it was AMAZING! Love these guys!!
The literal BEST. We ordered our wedding cake through them. We had a two-tier wedding cake and 3 mini cakes. One of the mini cakes was a suprise birthday cake for my husband! It was a last minute addition and it was a Marvel/comic book cake. They did a happy birthday banner on the cake and added pictures of my husband's favorite heroes. Frank was SO easy to work with and was super nice!! Everything was made clear to me on what we were getting. I gave them my color scheme and let them go at it! The cake decorator KILLED IT. Our cakes looked amazing and tasted even better!! We had salted caramel, lemon blueberry, confetti, red velvet, and white. We were getting compliments all night about the cake!!! AND they even delivered which took off some stress! 10/10 would order from them again!
I have gotten all my cakes from them in the last year and they never disappoint best bakery in Columbus well recommended
So many choices for whatever kind of sweet flavor you're craving! Highly recommend by me and my entire family!
We ordered our wedding cake from them and some cupcakes, and it was just a phenomenal experience. They were so great at taking our ideas and executing it even better than we imagined it. The staff is so kind and helpful every step of the way. Oh, and everything they make is beyond delicious. They have become our bakers for all future events. Thank you so much Sugar Rush!
Just wanted to give a shoutout to Sugar Rush Columbus. Their cookies in particular are so delicious and were a huge hit at our community Christmas event in Pataskala. They were even chosen out of 80+ stops as the best cookie in 2023. Highly recommend!
We loved our cake & cookies!!
Wonderfully amazing pumpkin donuts! Tried one as soon as I got to the car
I love this store. Everything I have ever had has been amazing and delicious and FUN. The kids love the "fancy milkshakes" and I love their fancy "adult drinks" and really, just everything about it.
Not only are the cakes beautiful, they are DELICIOUS!
The whole experience was great. From the initial phone call, to picking up and seeing what was created, to finally eating it. Highly suggest this bakery if you’d like something creative, something different. They listened to all my ideas then mixed that with their own take and what was made was an awesome cake for my son. Very happy! Thank you guys.
I was having a really bad afternoon one day and left a bad review. I apologize because this locally owned shop is amazing.
Response from the owner:❤️
I just came there for the breakfast today. And wow! I got some croissant, a classic cinnamon roll and the apple cinnamon roll! Absolutely loved everything. The cinnamon rolls were delicious but too sweet for my own taste. My husband who is a sweets lover absolutely adored and devoured it all! The croissant were my favorite! Sweet but not overly sweet. Can’t wait to return for more breakfast and normal everyday options! 10/10!!!!!
These cupcakes taste like heaven. They are fluffy and not too sweet. They are truly a work of art.
Very yummy treats, and extremely friendly staff.
We’ve gotten all of our special event desserts from here. From our wedding cake to our baby shower cupcakes they never fail to impress. Always friendly with great service and fresh products. Churro is the best flavor by far!
Definitely worth the stop while in Columbus! Service was awesome and let's talk about the sweet treats....WOW! We bought almost one if everything. It did not disappoint, so good!
Sugar rush ain't a Sugar rush without buying two of everything...
Staff was very friendly. Great shakes and sweets.
Cupcakes are Phenomenal! I had to go back and get more the very next day!
Today was the first time I have personally purchased from Sugar Rush, but have had their cakes from a friend. I had a large order that reserved online (super easy process by the way) for cinnamon rolls. I did not realize how huge these things were going to be! (Totally my bad, but they will get eaten!) I had a fairly large order with a bunch of cinnamon rolls, cupcakes, and cookies. I had my baby in the carseat and was somehow going to carry it all to the car, totally thinking multiple trips. The gentleman working there, that had taken care of me from start to finish, carried my stuff to my car. He was sooo amazing and sweet! I could not have had a better experience with them! Every single thing that I got was absolutely amazing!!!
I ordered just assorted cupcakes 🧁 These were the freshest best tasting cupcakes I've ever tasted. My hats off to you. Very satisfied.
Cake was amazing!! Frank really brought my vision to life with this cake, very impressed!
Stopped in today to get a last minute dessert for a birthday. They were so accommodating and easy to work with while I figured out what i wanted. SO MANY OPTIONS!
We have ordered take out treats several times. Always the best quality. While it is more expensive than the bakery at your grocery store, you get what you pay for. My family loves the Jason Samoa cup cakes, but I haven't gotten anything that wasn't delicious.
I love Sugar Rush . Came in today to get some quick cupcakes for our 3rd graders valentines party. We got everything we need . They are so amsome and believe me the name says it all . Great treats. Best place to go.
I ordered a custom engagement cake last week. The process was smooth and easy, and most importantly the cake was beautiful AND so moist and tasty. Several people asked me where it was from and even said it could be a contender for a wedding cake, which I agree. This rivals my favorite bakery in Dayton where I got married. We will use Sugar Rush in the future and especially once we have kids. Their designs are so fun!
Excellent local small business in Blacklick, Ohio. Custom cakes, amazing sweet treats and some gluten free options as well! Oh, did I mention their amazing and creative shakes and adult beverages? Check them out! Check out the macarons! Yum! I had to snap a pic before they disappeared! ❤️
Ww stopped in on a whim while out doing Christmas Shopping. The bakery ordering is separate from the bar...so by the time we ordered our pretzel an cupcakes we sat down and ended up skipping the bar which was a little unfortunate because some of the drinks sounded good...but as a side mentioned glitter in most. The pretzel was delicious but would feed 2-3 people and was heavily salted. I took the cupcakes home to enjoy later, I was super excited to find a pumpkin CC without cream cheese frosting as I am allergic. As someone with food allergies I was alarmed at a sign in the store. It included milk, nuts and the like which I expected. It also included shellfish which was one of my allergies and did surprise me at a bakery. I confirmed everything is made in house and there is no shellfish on site so it must be a goods manufacturing contamination possibility. I carry an EPI pen so I felt safe with the information and did not have any issues...but just in case you have a serious allergy be careful.
Mandy has made the treats for my daughter’s cheer team. We have had cookies, cake, cake pops and a Dubi bar. All were beautiful AND delicious. She also made cookies and cake to celebrate a life event. Sugar Rush Columbus is AMAZING. Don’t think twice, order small business TODAY!
Great place with amazing staff
Wow, very cool place. I didn't know that they serve alcohol also!!
I ordered a custom cake for my wife’s birthday party- vanilla cake with strawberry layers and an outside designed to look like the first edition of “The Hobbit”, my wife’s favorite book. I could not have been more impressed with the work if the decorator. It was so detailed and perfect, and it tasted as good as it looked! Will definitely come back for my custom cake needs.
Frank is a vibe. We love this company. They worked on our wedding cake, and not only did it look incredible, it tasted incredible. It was definitely the star of the evenings. Wedding aside, we come in here often for desserts, and they don't disappoint.
Joshua was so nice and their bathrooms were awesome and clean ! Thank you for a wonderful experience kid approved
Once again, Sugar Rush knocked it out of the park. The cake, cupcakes and cookies were fantastic for my daughter’s birthday. My daughter loved the surprise horror theme cake design. The service was great when we walked in, the young lady working the front was patient with us as we were picking out cupcakes and cookies , even gave us some recommendations on her favorites. If you haven’t tried them, definitely recommend. You won’t be disappointed.
I ordered a Taylor Swift birthday cake for my daughter’s seventh birthday, and it came out exactly as I pictured it. It was delicious as well.
We came in just before they closed for my friends birthday and they made us yummy drinks and let us stay to enjoy them. I felt so bad but we appreciated you all so much. Thank you!!!!

Local Businesses
We Recommend